Review for The Treatment

Review for The Treatment

I read an ARC edition of this book for a bookclub on So there may be things that have been fixed in the official book that were still around in this one.

I have been looking forward to this book for a long long time, so I was really fangirling when I saw it on Hebban, and even more fangirling when I was selected to participate!

I am always looking around for good YA thriller mysteries, plus I cannot resist one that features an academy with brainwashing and mysterious going-on’s.

Our MC, Drew, was quite an interesting character, though her plans do need a lot more work. 😛 But credit were credit is due, she is brave and I love her dedication to her family. How she does that for her brother. A lot of other people may just have done some basic research and then let the police handle it, but she goes undercover in the institute.
I loved how easily she made friends with Mouse (how she didn’t mind that the girl was different than her and that she was a bit awkward in the beginning) and how she decided to help out the girl. Drew also brought Mouse out of her shell, you could really see a change happening and I was so happy. For Drew, as she found someone she can confide in, for Mouse for a friend who will help her out.

The academy/institute was quite creepy, even before we know what the Treatment truly entails I was already not believing that this was a good place. It was just too good, the way the kids were treated, the schedule, the speeches. There was just something really off about it all, and I wondered how some kids were hoping so hard for the treatment. Then again, I guess given all the fun you get before it all, it is easy to forget how you will turn out in the end. Though there were a few kids here and there who just knew what may happen (like Israel, who was one of my favourite side characters).

Plus later on she did a great job on pretending to be x. It must have been so hard for her, especially nearer to certain events and when she heard about y. I was really amazed.

There were parts that were a bit slow, or were it felt the story wasn’t going anywhere. But thankfully there were also enough faster paced parts.

I also love that the mom was so dedicated to her kids, how, regardless of her new hubby, she still believed in her kids and tried to do her best to be there for them (in the beginning at least).

Jude was just a pest. She quite well ruined a fair bit of the book with her crappy attitude. She just didn’t make sense. She wanted to be included, but didn’t want to be included. She wanted to escape, but then she would just shout out all the secrets. She wanted people to be nice and trusting, but then she would kick them when they are down. I could go on, but I just wanted her gone. I am removing 0.5 stars from the book because of her.

That brings me to Lacey. What a terrible, terrible character she was. I really dislike the popular mean girl trope. I also didn’t get why the institute, when Mouse left, added Lacey to Drew’s dorm. I am pretty, no perfectly, sure that there should be something in Drew’s file about Lacey. How she punched Lacey and also about their history before that. Why the hell would you put that person in the same dorm? And also how the hell did Lacey end up there all of the sudden? Did she do something wrong? As I can’t imagine her petty bullying would go so far that she would stalk her prey all the way out in the country.

The brainwashing part? I was really looking forward to it, seeing how it happened and what would happen to the characters, but in the end it was disappointing. Especially considering how easily it was undone. We see our MC go through a harrowing experience, getting zapped, hurt, tortured, but as soon as she gets locked inside a locker and gets a bad case of claustrophobia she is magically and instantly fixed. Whut? I am not a major in psychology, but I found this very very weird. Plus it made everything seem so much less worse. Plus I am also wondering how the other kids (as there are some others out there already) are doing, I am sure those with common fears (spiders/clowns) would already have had their brainwashing undone, but I am guessing only our MC and then later her friends are magically fixed. Especially considering what the dad says, that he is working on a treatment. But why would you? Just give those kids their “worst” fears or a good death experience (like drowning) and within a few minutes they are cured. *sighs*

Hilarious: at one point in the beginning the mom leaves the institute (she brought Drew there) and it is said that it is 5 pm. But when one of the important guys talks to her and asks her where she is going, asks if she wants to share a cab, he mentions lunch. Lunch? At 5pm? Whut?

I did like the revelation near the end (though I could see it coming a mile away). Poor x, poor Drew, poor Mason, poor mom. Yes, I quite like the end, though I was a bit sad that it felt a bit rushed. Also I am a bit confused about the guy in the bushes, it was just ignored, but why add it then if you are brushing it off like this?

All in all, I still enjoyed it. The escape plans, the institute, Drew, Mason, Mouse, the Treatment was quite creepy (well up to the point of what I mentioned in the spoiler). I would still recommend this one.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: