Review: The Shadows of Who We Once Were, Vol. 1

Review: The Shadows of Who We Once Were, Vol. 1

The Shadows of Who We Once Were, Vol. 1 by Yae Utsumi, Red cover with a guy standing in a classroom in redOH WOW. OK. This was, as we Dutch would call it, heftig. A reunion, experiments, death, poison.

I was browsing through Google Play for some new books and came across this manga, I was immediately intrigued by the premise. Reunion. Murder. I was maybe a dash uncertain as I wasn’t the biggest fan of the mangaka’s other book (Until Your Bones Rot), but I was still willing to try it out. And I am happy I did!

In this one it is time for a reunion between friends/classmates. They haven’t seen each other in years and so everyone is present <spoiler>(and well, given what happens to the one who didn’t come… I guess there was no choice)</spoiler>. They think it is just going to be a fun few days in the school building before it is destroyed. They are happy to see each other again and some of them changed A LOT, which made me laugh. But quickly things go very dark when they find out what happened to one of them and when they try to run… well they find out even more bad things. I was shocked at how fast it went from a happy reunion to oh well we are fucked now. We see that Mikio (a guy I am still not sure about, I mean, I didn’t believe his excuse for this whole thing, it feels like there is much more to it) has planned some dark experiments and is willing to go very far. Not participating in the experiments is a no-go. You have to be part.

And we see how these bonds are easily broken when under strain. We see that the characters who look all to be pretty normal and sweet have some dark secrets, dark things going on, things that happened in the past when they were classmates. Like how one girl was bullied and raped but didn’t tell anyone. How someone acted like they weren’t friends with someone. It was quite interesting to see the group fall apart and so fast. Given what we learned at the start it seemed that this was such a wonderful class, but apparently nope. I am intrigued to see what is coming next, because I am sure there are many more secrets and darkness + someone has poison now, oh yes. Mikio isn’t the only one doing the bad things.

I loved that the book started with a news report on the situation including the deaths, some may see it as a spoiler, but it made me even more curious about the book. Who was going to die in those ways? Who would survive? Why was this happening?
Plus, I loved that twice throughout the manga we saw two classmates who survived and tells us a hint/gives us a bit of the puzzle.

The art was pretty good. The style fits great with the kind of story it is, though the deaths felt a bit weird/over done.

But, if you are looking for a psychological horror read then this is your book. I will be reading this manga further because I need to know how it goes.

Star rating, 4 stars

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.